How to Increase Self Storage Sales Conversion Rates

According to the annual Self Storage Association Report 2025, phone conversion rates for self-storage have fallen from 65% to just 57%.

So, what's going on? While everyone's busy blaming the market, the answer might be slightly different: it could be how quickly you respond, how persistently you follow up, and whether your sales approach actually connects with today's customers.

I've spent the last eight years working with storage facilities across the UK through Stashbee, and this article consists of all the know-how I’ve gathered through the years. Here are some potential reasons why your leads aren't converting, and exactly what to do about it.
 

Speed Beats Everything Else

Nothing - and I mean nothing - impacts conversion rates like response time.

According to Harvard Business Review, facilities that reach potential customers within a minute of their enquiry convert almost 400% better than those who take 30+ minutes. And that’s not all: nearly 8 out of 10 customers end up choosing whoever gets back to them first.

"But we can't just sit by the phone all day!"

Storage operations are busy places. You've got maintenance issues, walk-ins, security concerns - I get it. But the truth is, if you wait more than 5 minutes to respond, your conversion chances drop by 80%.

One idea you can implement almost immediately is creating two-hour "response shifts" where team members take turns handling incoming enquiries.

Right now, I want you to think about this: When someone reaches out about storage, how many minutes pass before they're talking to someone from your team?

Stop Giving Up After One Call

44% of their leads get exactly ONE follow-up call.

One.

Meanwhile, according to NSEA (National Sales Executive Association), 80% of successful conversions happen only after FIVE or more follow-up attempts.

You read that right. If you're not trying at least 5 times, you're throwing away most of your potential customers.

What actually works? A system like this:

• Call within 5 minutes of getting the lead
• If no answer, try again within 2 hours
• Third attempt: next day, opposite time of day
• Fourth attempt: 24 hours after first contact
• Fifth attempt: 48 hours after first contact

And it’s best not to call at the same time repeatedly. If they didn't answer during work hours, try evening. If they missed your morning call, try lunch time.

In this digital era, you might even want to layer on some additional options for your customers, such as text messages and emails. You could even add a link within your message or email to provide customers with a time slot of when to call you. Loads of people these days preferred to be contacted via text or email, so if you think your calling strategy isn’t working as well as you expected, try this instead. 

Does your team have a specific, written follow-up process? If not, now’s the right time to create one.
 

Your Sales Team Needs These Three Skills

I've listened to hundreds of recorded sales calls, and the difference between high converters and everyone else comes down to three specific skills:

They Actually Listen

Storage isn't just about square footage. People need storage during major life changes - moving, downsizing, divorce, business expansion. Your best performers don't just hear unit requirements; they understand the situation behind the need.

They Handle Objections Without Stumbling

When someone hesitates about price or terms, average performers get flustered. Top performers have ready answers for:

• "Why is climate control so expensive?"
• "What if I need to move out sooner?"
• "How accessible is my unit on holidays?"

They Create Natural Urgency

The best salespeople never pressure customers, but they do highlight reality: "Based on your needs, we have three units that would work well. Given our current occupancy trends, I'd suggest securing one soon - would you like me to hold one while you decide?"

According to SSA UK, teams trained specifically on these skills typically convert 15-20% better than those without focused training.

Your Hours Don't Match When People Are Looking

About 40% of all storage enquiries happen during evenings and weekends.

Guess when most facilities are closed or minimally staffed? Evenings and weekends.

This creates a massive gap in your conversion funnel. While potential customers are actively searching, many facilities simply aren't there to respond. By Monday morning, those leads have usually signed with whoever was available when they needed answers.

Some solutions that work:

• Call forwarding after hours
• Weekend rotation schedules
• Alert systems that notify on-call staff when enquiries come in

If someone enquires at 7PM Saturday, does your facility respond within minutes or make them wait until Monday?

Stop Making These Mistakes

After seeing hundreds of storage operations, certain patterns keep emerging:

Sending an email isn’t enough

Phone calls convert up to 10x better than email. Email has its place, but it should support - not replace - actual conversation. When someone's actively looking for storage, nothing beats a human voice addressing their specific situation.
 

Not all enquiries are created equal

Smart operators recognise buying signals. When someone mentions an exact move-in date, specifies precise requirements, or asks detailed questions about security, they're showing stronger intent. These leads deserve priority treatment.

At Stashbee, we pre-qualify leads before sending them your way. We confirm contact details, capture specific requirements, and verify interest level - so your team can focus on closing, not qualifying.

Better conversion doesn't just impact this month's numbers. Each converted lead means potential years of recurring revenue and referrals.

via GIPHY

Reality Check

Questions for you to take away and evaluate within your facility’s operations:

1. Does your team respond to enquiries within 5 minutes?
2. Do you attempt at least 5 follow-ups before marking a lead "cold"?
3. Has your sales team been specifically trained on handling common objections?
4. Can you respond to enquiries during evenings and weekends?

Turn Leads into Loyalty with Stashbee

If you're looking to fill your pipeline with quality leads while implementing these improvements, that's exactly where Stashbee can help. Our lead generation system delivers pre-qualified storage enquiries directly to your team - people who are actively searching and ready to make decisions. We've already confirmed their contact details and specific requirements, so you can focus on what matters: having those meaningful conversations that convert. I genuinely hope you’ve found these tips helpful. Here's to better conversion rates in 2025!